book cover for A Little Naughty: A Matchmaker Reverse Harem Romance (Small Town Lovers Book 3) by Pepper Swan

Holiday Reverse Harems (AKA Hallmark of RH) – Part 1

Hello fellow readers!

In honor of Hallmark Movie season, I mean the holiday season, I’ve put together a part one list for Holiday Reverse Harems (AKA the Hallmark of R.H.).

I tried to find books that are either holiday-related, family-oriented or have the Hallmark movie vibe.  

As always, descriptions are verbatim from Amazon. As an amazon associate, I earn commission on qualifying purchases.

Pssssst: Did you nominate your favorite 2021 R.H. book yet? If not, head over here and select your favorite! 

Be well, and happy reading! And to all my friends stateside, Happy Thanksgiving!

Amazon Description

I’d lost my belief in Christmas…
Until 3 wise men helped to revive my faith.
But will this feeling last or is it simply Christmas magic?

There’s Nick Morgenstern, possibly the most eligible bachelor in all of Cricket, with his smooth moves, bad boy reputation and drool worthy good looks.

Kris Cruz has soulful eyes, and a hard body that causes me to swoon every time he comes anywhere around me.

And Rudy Camarari who I’ve had a crush on since high school after only one heart-pounding, heat-filled kiss that is once again taunting my holiday dreams.

I’d wanted to get through this Christmas season without incident and without having to attend any of the town’s over-the-top holiday festivities.

Problem is the 3 grannies like to play matchmaker, and have each talked me into a date with their grandsons… who they each claim is perfect for me. I can’t refuse these amazing ladies, not when I owe them so much.

Now, I’m dating 3 enchanting men, and I'm loving the Christmas season once again. When the grannies ask me privately to choose my favorite grandson, I have no choice but to tell each of them the truth… their particular grandson is my favorite.

Is this a Christmas miracle or are the three grannies right? Each of their grandsons is perfect for me… all three of them.

A Little Naughty is a sizzling, small-town reverse harem romance. It’s rich with sexy single and multiple partner scenes all done with a touch of humor that just might melt your Kindle. As with all my books, a HEA is always guaranteed… Thanks for reading!

Thoughts from Paige

Although this is the third in the series, it looks to be one you can read as a standalone.  

Amazon Description

Tis the season to be grateful - times two!

I knew attending this charity function was a bad idea. However, I didn’t know being bad was so much fun.

When I met Nate and Callen, I found them impossible to resist even though I was foolish enough to try. It didn’t take long to realize the undeniable chemistry that exists between the three of us. As it turns out, I need them like I need air.

These muscular umber alpha twin males are more than just good looks. The problem? Somewhere amongst the fun I’ve developed real feelings for them. No one told me true love comes with a price, though. Our relationship isn’t conventional and there are some people who would rather see us apart and miserable then together and happy.

Additionally, I worry Nate and Callen are too good to be true. I keep waiting for the other shoe to drop because life has taught me that there’s always something being held back. Cue Thanksgiving Day when all hell breaks loose.

18+ only. This is a holiday reverse harem MFM romance. No cliffhangers. No cheating. HEA guaranteed.

Thoughts from Paige
Heads up, peeps, the author has three books out, one an anthology, and the other two (including this) are both listed as the first book in a series. No second book yet. Unfortunate as the reviews for this book are glowing. I'm torn about reading it; I hate unanswered questions. Let me know if you happen to have info on when the second may be published!

Amazon Description

What do you do when you have a huge crush on your best friend, or in my case best friends?

I’ve spent most of my life being the girl who tags along with the Love Triplets.
Three hot specimens, identical to most, but different in every way to me.

There’s Alex, the high school quarterback, whose deep, blue eyes I swear can see my soul.
Aiden, the smartest boy I know, who shares my love of academics and soccer. His nerdy talk twists me up inside. And Archer, the funniest person alive, whose full lips I’d die to taste. Don’t get me started on how he looks in gray baseball pants.

I was doing great suppressing my feelings and acting like every day was just another day. Unt ileverything changed. When the secret they’ve been keeping comes unraveled, and my arch-nemesis attacks in every way she can, will our friendship even survive?

All my Loves is the first novella in the Love Brothers duet. It’s a #whychoose, reverse harem romance, with lots of steam and a HFN.

Thoughts from Paige
I know I've read this, and I think I liked it.  I don't remember it though, so although it's not a negative review it isn't a glowing one either.  I'll update if I re-read it.  Sounds like a hallmark type plot, so I'm keeping it.

Amazon Description

I just wanted to make the perfect turkey.

The newest addition to my harem had never had a traditional Thanksgiving. Charlie's magic family didn't celebrate mortal traditions. My other two men, the broody vampire and energetic sprite, had experienced my takeout holidays before.
But this year, Thanksgiving was going to be perfect.

I was cooking and I wasn't using an ounce of witchy magic.

Unfortunately, those plans were straight out of the bad-idea-box, because a rival witch who wants my men cursed my house. Now the elves annual mating ritual is descending on my dining room and the master of ceremonies thinks I'm a catch.
If it's not bad enough that there are elves banging all over my house, there's an ancient fairy force coming to the party, who are hell bent on destroying the elven race and anyone near them.

Happy Thanksgiving to me.

Thoughts from Paige
This is definitely on here for the holiday element, NOT the hallmark element.
The title doesn't make it sound interesting, tut the reviews mentioned this bing a hilarious book.  Bonus to us, it's available on audible.

Amazon Description

There's never been a Thanksgiving with this much spice.
Return to Holiday Harbor for another epic holiday romance adventure.

All I want is to keep my family’s land.
Only being alone isn’t that easy.
Especially in a small town like Holiday Harbor.
Billionaire Bennett Carpenter thinks he can take the land from me.
He has no idea how determined I am to keep what’s mine.
He shows up with his best friend Kane.
Now I’m not sure how to keep these walls up when they look like that.
Two men ready to prove they want more than just a deed.
They want my heart and body together.

It’s supposed to be a holiday getaway for Thanksgiving.
But neither of us thought we’d meet her.
Now everything has flipped upside down.
All we want is to help Hope, but she’s stubborn and likes things her way.
We don’t have much time to prove to her we are the men she deserves.
The clock is ticking. She could lose everything she loves.
We can make her nights hotter than any flame she’s touched.
She just has to let us both in.
Before Thanksgiving.

**Double Giving Trouble is a Holiday MFM menage romance with MF and MFM scenes. There is NO cheating, NO cliffhanger and a guaranteed HEA with plenty of steam. Holiday Harbor series books can be read in any order**

Amazon Description

They say two is better than one...
But what about three?

I'm a babysitter for three hot single dads.
All of whom want to date me.
And all of whom want me to be a part of their Father's Day.
Their rivalry over me causes friction between them,
Even though I'd rather have a different kind of friction between us.
I can't decide between them, so the game is on.
They'll each take me out on a date.
And the winner will have my presence for the holiday.
But what if I like all of them?
And if they each start to like each other?

Could we have a combined Father's Day...
And maybe by next year, another baby on the way?

Four Father's Dates is an MMFM bisexual reverse harem romance with no cheating and no cliffhangers; just a lot of steamy goodness and a happily ever after for all.

Thoughts from Paige: 
I have downloaded this to read, but haven't had a chance yet as of this post.

Amazon Description

From Book 1: Four contractors, good with their hands and willing to share. Does this good girl have it in her to say yes to her handymen?

My name's Piper Drake, and I have a problem. When I take a look at my late grandfather's long-abandoned house after learning he left it to me, one thing comes to mind: a listing titled For Sale: One Handyman Special.

That's before I meet the four hunky handymen Grandpa arranged to do the renovations. Childhood friend Carter, brooding Jace, golden boy Luke and sports-loving Trey are beyond drool-worthy... and I do more than my fair share of drooling.

When my apartment building is sold and I have no choice but to move onto the property, there's no shortage of eye candy to spark my interest - though I have to wonder if there's maybe something wrong with me, crushing on four men at a time like I do.

Or am I onto something? Because after weeks of fighting the attraction, the guys reveal something I could never have imagined in my wildest dreams.

Do I have it in me to go with my heart and accept all four of them into my life?

HANDYMAN SPECIAL is Book One of Six in the Handymen Series, a contemporary romance with plenty of comedy, drama and emotion. It is NOT a standalone and features a HFN ending in terms of the romantic relationships. The story extends over the course of the series, but the devotion of Piper's handymen is never in question.

Thoughts from Paige

The latest novella came up during my research for this post. I wanted to take a quick peek at the first book to ensure it would be an okay fit, and I wound up reading the first two novellas. These are HEAVY on the sexy times. I like books with character development; slow/medium burn is my jam. Unfortunately, I didn't feel character growth or any sparks on how they got to know each other. That being said, I'm planning on finishing the series, and it is a nice easy read.

P.S. There are a LOT of sexy times. And this is such a stressful time of year. This is an excellent book to pair with a glass of wine and your favorite...massager.

Amazon Description

Book Summary:Being a single mom isn’t easy. It’s not for the faint of heart, but it’s a life I’d never give up. Now, learning to date while being a single mom?It’s nearly impossible.Everything is online. I’ve been out of the game for nearly a decade, and the rules to dating have changed. What does this mean for me?What happens when I like more than one prospect?Well, I guess we’ll see how many misadventures I can get into by diving into the virtual world. Please note: This is a Reverse Harem

Thoughts from Paige
I don't think I can get much closer to a Hallmark movie plot than this book.

Amazon Description

Phantom of the Opera meets Steamy Reverse Harem Romance when Nadia is shared by her four gorgeous theater colleagues.

My first time on Tinder was a doozy.
Four handsome theater men when all I expected was one.
But then they laid a breathtaking proposition on me.
One that dropped me, quite literally, to my knees.
They want to share me…. In every way.

Ryan, the redheaded stagehand bulging with muscle, is looking for a friends-with-benefits situation.
Andy, the bespectacled lighting technician with the body of Adonis, wants to court me on elaborate dates for a long-term relationship.
Dorian, the slender actor with long hair and a dramatic flair, just wants a platonic friend.
And Braden, the beautiful lead actor who I have a huge crush on? He needs a pretend-girlfriend to get his parents off his back.

Juggling these four gorgeous men ends up being harder than I ever expected.
Especially when Dorian and I become more than just friends, and my fake relationship with Braden turns into something very real.
But something strange is happening at the theater.
Malfunctioning lights, equipment crashing to the stage, and broken trapdoors—it seems a saboteur is determined to stop us from making it to opening night.
And the worst part? Everyone thinks the saboteur is me.

Can I find a way to balance the intense love from these four amazing guys?
Or will I end up the saboteur’s final victim on opening night?

THE PROPOSITION is a suspenseful, steamy Reverse Harem Romance filled with humor, action, and a shocking twist-ending. It also contains sizzling hot menage encounters, in single and multiple partner scenes. HEA guaranteed!

Amazon Description

Margo was just your normal Christmas elf, and sure maybe she had a bit too much Christmas cheer, but hey, if starting to decorate for Christmas in July was wrong, she didn't want to be right.

At least, until the three lords of Halloween decide to kidnap her and bring her back to Halloweenland.

There’s Jack, the hopelessly sexy and tall King of Halloween, who’s harboring a monster inside of him.

Wraith, the dark and dangerous Boogeyman, who may not be nearly as evil as he seems.

And Sam, the Mayor of Halloweenland, whose multiple personalities only seem to make him sexier.

And Margo’s about to find out exactly what goes bump in the night, but with any luck... maybe she can spread a little Christmas cheer to these three dark beings. After all, that's her only hope...

Thoughts from Paige
I cannot wait to give this a read!! One of the reviews likened this to a remake of The Nightmare before Christmas.  Sounds so awesome!

Amazon Description

This kitty loves to play with baubles…

Four years into being a mother, Kat needs a break. She's barely killed anyone since she gave birth and the panther within her is frustrated. She needs blood, murder and mayhem.

When she's offered the chance to infiltrate a strange cult's annual festivities, there's no stopping her. Along with her three devoted mates, Kat will have to look beyond the holiday cheer to find a killer.

A Christmas sequel to the bestselling Catnip Assassin series, an urban fantasy reverse harem romance featuring a bloodthirsty cat shifter assassin and her hunky mates. A book to warm you in the depth of winter.

This book can be enjoyed as a standalone without having previously read the Catnip Assassins series.

Amazon Description

They were three ripped, gorgeous studs. Drawn together by a common goal, and a willingness to share absolutely everything... including me.

I never expected to end up in Scotland, renovating a castle of all things! But fate landed me here, just as it brought me two sizzling construction workers and a breathtaking, tattooed stonemason. Three fellow Americans hellbent on helping me keep the property from going back up for auction.

But something sinister has been showing up at night, out near the woods. And when outside forces start aligning against me, my three amazing saviors propose a very unorthodox, unconventional arrangement... involving the three of them, and me.

First Julian, broad-shouldered and gargantuan, deliciously tattooed and powerful beyond my wildest dreams. Noah, the Brooklyn-raised transplant, shredded and beautiful yet harboring a mysterious past. Finally, Chase - Green-eyed and gorgeous, with model good looks. The jawline of a Greek god, and a smile that would set off an explosion of butterflies in any girl's stomach.

Together we're an unstoppable team; an insatiable maelstrom of dripping hot chemistry, with me lost in a sea of rock-hard abs and rippling muscle.

But Castle Westgate also hides its own forbidden secret. One so incredible, that if finally revealed, could intertwine all four of our lives forever...

UNCONVENTIONAL is a sizzling, stand-alone reverse harem love story filled with humor, suspense, and molten hot action, in single and multiple partner scenes, hot enough to melt your kindle. HEA guaranteed!

Thoughts by Paige
This was a cute, easy RH read.  Definitely has the Hallmark vibes.

1 thought on “Holiday Reverse Harems (AKA Hallmark of RH) – Part 1”

  1. Pingback: HOLIDAY REVERSE HAREMS – PART 3 – The Naughty Book Box

Leave a Reply

Scroll to Top


Join the mailing list to receive the latest news and updates.

%d bloggers like this: